27 thoughtful gift ideas for jewelry lovers this holiday

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, Rolling Stone may earn an affiliate commission.

You can’t explain what it feels like to be gifted jewelry-partly because it’s hard to pinpoint personal feelings, but also because when you’re gifted the right thing, it’s as if the other person sees you fully. Suddenly, this small gift becomes the embodiment of your personality. Sounds magical, doesn’t it?

Says Morgan Lang, Creative Director and Founder of AGMES: “Thoughtful and personalized gifts always have that extra special quality that makes you want to keep it forever and think about the person who gave it to you.” Rolling Stone. “The popularity of heart-shaped jewelry makes me think that people are excited to show love – I think that’s why we’ve seen so many people choosing our carved heart necklace lately.”

Not sure what makes the perfect jewelry gift? Don’t worry; you’re not alone. We’ve identified some pieces that are perfect for gifting as keepsakes, from trending picks and personal experiences with the brands we swear by. These products are sure to catch the attention of your loved ones and make the perfect gift any time of the year.

Best Jewelry Gift Ideas for the Holidays

AGMES Baroque Bodmer Earrings

There is something special about pearl jewelry that conveys more affection than diamonds. Perhaps this is nature being made, protected and nurtured by another living being. For your significant other this holiday, try gifting them a pair of AGMES Baroque Bodmer earrings, which will convey the intimacy and love you feel for them with an extra touch.

Reedy Men’s Fleur de Lis Tassel Chain Lapel Pin

Men’s Wearhouse isn’t the first place you think of when you’re shopping for men’s jewelry, but the store’s website has upped its game in recent years, with unique offerings that go beyond standard cufflinks and watches (though they have a good selection of that, too). This season, opt for something different and get the tassel chain lapel pin, which offers a modern alternative to wearing a tie. Pin the smaller end of the pin to your lapel or chest pocket, then pin the other end under your collar. The Fleur de Lys symbol is a classic idea that never goes out of style. It’s a great gift idea for men who want to have a little “sparkle” without going overboard, and it’s sure to be an unexpected gift as well.

Miabella paperclip chain necklace

Balance light and delicate jewelry with a utilitarian-inspired design. This Miabella paper chain necklace is an excellent choice for him and her. Due to its sleek and bold style, it’s also great to wear with other pieces that your friend or partner may already own. Available in 18K gold and sterling silver.

Etica Crystal Albinism Necklace

Shopping for someone who loves layers on their neck? Try gifting them this Ettika Crystal Lariat Necklace. The 18-karat gold-plated chain is elegant and layered around the neck with dangling zirconia details for added intrigue.

18-karat gold-plated bracelet

One of the most notable trends at the Spring 2024 shows was the move towards organic shapes and nautical themes. From Schiaparelli’s absurd lobster-shaped necklace to Louis Vuitton’s modern pearl-embroidered collections, this under-the-sea movement is vast and sweeping. However, our approach is far more subtle, as our 18-karat gold-plated Botesa bracelet embraces organic coral shapes without overt messaging.

Necklace from the David Yurman Box Series

David Yurman has been in the fine jewelry industry since the 1980s and has quickly become one of the most recognizable brands on the market in terms of quality and design. For that special someone on your list this year, consider gifting this David Yurman chain necklace, which is made of sterling silver and comes in a range of lengths to suit your partner’s style.

Jennifer Fisher Gamma-Hughes

Hoops are a staple of jewelry as a gift. If you’re shopping for someone who loves earrings, consider updating their old pieces with these Jennifer Fisher Walk Micro Huggies glasses. Made from 14k gold plating or sterling silver, this is a great smaller set.

Craighill Radial Cuff

Designed to be “practical and timeless because it’s beautiful and interesting,” Craighill is a relatively new brand with a lot of appeal. Although they sell stunning pieces like the Craighill Radial Cuff, they also make incredibly stylish products, ranging from home goods to stationery.

VEERT white gold freshwater pearl necklace

Pearl strands are no longer just for her. In recent years (and popularized by artists like Jayhawk and Pharrell), they’ve become pieces of jewelry that anyone can enjoy. Consider gifting him a pearl necklace, such as the VEERT necklace in white gold and freshwater pearls. It balances masculinity and femininity wonderfully and looks great worn alone or stacked.

Migori Jewel Charm

Jewelry with a personal touch is a sentimental gift that provides timeless memories and longevity beyond most trends. Consider giving this Mejuri birthstone charm that can be attached to any chain or bracelet your loved one may own.

Pavoi earrings

Classic studs are always a great option for gifting someone who may not already have them. For someone on a budget, these PAVOI stud earrings are beautiful, available in 14k yellow, rose, or white gold, and at a price that’s hard to beat.

The pearl chain represents

There’s nothing like wearing a set of pearls. Whether you’re looking to dress up or down, pearls can instantly take your look from 0 to 100. If you’re looking for something classic, this collection from Represent is the perfect choice to live in your collection forever.

Michael Kors Silver Clasp Necklace

Go for something that’s steeped in tradition, like this silver-colored lock necklace from Michael Kors. It’s a unique lock shape that symbolizes love and devotion but is designed as a pendant. It’s not too far out of reach, making it an excellent gift if you’re not sure what to buy.

Diesel gold-colored stainless steel chain bracelet

Creative Director Glenn Martens’ specialty is taking traditional designs and amplifying them just enough to feel modern. For example, Diesel’s gold-colored stainless steel chain bracelet is a classic link style, but the alternating sizes feel fresh. Not to mention, the stainless steel material is durable enough to maintain its luster in any environment.

Mesoma Aluminum Silicate Donut Drop Earrings

Moonstone is not a common stone to see in fine jewelry, which makes the Missoma Donut Moonstone drop earrings a rare and beautiful find. The organic donut shape, encased in 18-karat gold, is a bold yet elegant shape, appealing to any ear shape.

Migori Round Box Chain Necklace

Shopping for someone with a chain? Give them the Mejuri Square Box Chain Pendant. It comes in four different materials, but we’re really surprised by the choice of black titanium which is incredibly uncommon, especially for box chains.

Monica Vinader linear chain bracelet

An elegant take on the classic friendship bracelet, the Monica Vinader Linear Chain Bracelet is a great gift for the special people in your life. Available in 18K gold, rose gold or sterling silver, make it extra special and have it engraved for free with purchase.

AGMES Collarbone Necklace

Born from the mind of founder Morgan Lang and handcrafted in New York, AGMES blends sculptural designs with fine jewelry. Among its high-quality collections, the organic shape of this AGMES Wishbone necklace, made in black suede or ivory cord, sterling silver or gold, is a great choice for the creative person in your life.

Monica Vinader small pearl bracelet

If you’re looking for more youthful fine jewelry, the Monica Vinader Mini Nugget Pearl Bracelet is a beautiful choice. Made of 18-karat gold and pearls, its delicate beaded design looks stunning on the wrist and is easy to wear with other designs.

Etika 3 stacked rings

Stacking rings has become a huge trend in the past few years, which means this is a great gift for the ring wearer in your life. The Ettika 3 Stack Rings can be mixed and matched with styles that others may already own or can be worn on their own for something more simple.

Molten Mesoma Twisted Pendant Necklace

A statement necklace can go a long way, and the Missoma Molten Twisted Pendant Necklace epitomizes that. Its thin chain fits perfectly with other pendant-shaped necklaces, contrasts with the twisted pendant that stands out and pairs well with the Missoma Donut Moonstone drop earrings – made in 18-karat gold plate.

AGMES Small Astrid Cuff

If you’re shopping for someone who enjoys simplicity, the AGMES Small Astrid Cuff is a great choice for a gift. Its sculptural, organic design is interesting enough to hold space on the wrist alone without being too bold. Designed in either sterling silver or gold and comes in sizes S/M and M/L.

Stainless Steel Diesel Chain Pendant

For the enthusiastic and “brave” person in your life who loves a statement piece, gift them this Diesel Stainless Steel Chain Necklace. The smaller Cuban chains won’t feel heavy on the neck, but their thickness and density make a bold statement on the neck.

Monica Vinader Upholstered Woven Heart

Show someone you love them with this woven heart necklace from Monica Vinader. Its thin 18-karat gold chain is light enough to wear with other necklaces, but the intimacy of the pendant takes gift-giving to a whole different level.

Aobei 18K Gold Small Pearl Bracelet

If a full set of pearls doesn’t suit your partner’s style, try something simpler like Aobei’s 18-karat gold mini pearl bracelet. It’s more subtle than a necklace but still gives the emotional appeal that only pearls can provide.

Songmix Jewelry Box with Glass Lid

If you’re still unsure or don’t want to risk gifting the wrong thing, there’s nothing jewelry lovers care more about than organizing their unique collection. The SONGMICS jewelry box with glass lid comes in a range of colors, ideally suited to your friend or partner’s style.

MFXIP Travel Jewelry Bag

For jewelry lovers on the go, this MFXIP Travel Jewelry Bag is also a great gift for anyone on your list, especially if you’re hinting at some future trips as an extra gift (wink). With dimensions of 3.9 x 3.9 x 2, it fits perfectly in a suitcase or travel bag.

How to choose the best jewelry for gifting

Style is incredibly personal. That’s why we take great care in selecting the clothing, shoes, handbags, and jewelry we offer to our readers. While we review trends to showcase on-trend selections, we also rely on promising customer feedback or direct experience with products and brands. The result is a carefully considered shopping list with you in mind.

Do you pride yourself on shopping only the best picks when it comes to fashion? We do too. We’re tastemakers committed to offering the finest clothing, shoes, and accessories. Shop like a Rolling Stone Editor and check out more of our recommendations.